All posts
For HomeownersConstruction QA
5 min read

How to get a second opinion on contractor work

Another contractor, a home inspector, an engineer, or a remote Professional Review. What each one costs and which question it actually answers.

Something about the work doesn't look right. Maybe the grout lines wander. Maybe the deck feels bouncy. Maybe the contractor said “that's normal” one too many times. You want someone who knows the trade to tell you if you're right.

There are four ways to get that second opinion. They cost very different amounts and answer very different questions.

1. Ask another contractor to come look

Cost: often free. What you get: a quick opinion, usually verbal.

The catch is the incentive. A competing contractor has a reason to find problems, because problems become their job. Some will be honest. Some will tell you everything needs to come out. And most won't write anything down, so you have nothing to bring back to the original contractor.

2. Hire a home inspector

Cost: usually a few hundred dollars and up. What you get: a broad report on the whole house.

Home inspectors are trained for the sale of a house. They look wide, not deep. Many will note that tile is “cracked” or a floor is “uneven” without saying whether it's a workmanship defect or how it should be fixed. They're also not always available mid-project, when the answer matters most.

3. Hire a specialist or engineer

Cost: often several hundred to a few thousand dollars. What you get: a deep, formal assessment.

If you suspect a structural problem, a failing foundation, or you're heading to court, this is the right call. For most workmanship questions, like tile, framing, drywall, decks, windows, it's more than you need.

4. Get a remote Professional Review

Cost: $49. What you get: a written Review from a licensed pro in the trade, based on your photos.

This is what we built Let Me Take A Look to do. You upload photos and documents of the work. A vetted pro who works in that trade claims it, looks at every photo, and pins each concern directly on the image with a severity: info, concern, or red flag. You get a written Review with the findings, the red flags, and next steps. You also get a short Q&A window to ask follow-ups.

The reviewer has no relationship with your contractor and no interest in getting the job. We don't refer you to anyone and there's nothing to upsell.

Which one fits

  • You want a quick read on visible work (tile, drywall, trim, paint, decking, a shower pan before tile): a remote Review.
  • You're buying or selling a house: a home inspector.
  • You suspect structural failure, or you're in litigation: a structural engineer or specialist.
  • You want a replacement bid: another contractor, once you already know what's wrong.

How to get the most out of any second opinion

  • Take photos in good light, wide shots first, then close-ups.
  • Put a ruler, level, or coin in frame so size and slope are readable.
  • Include the scope of work or contract language for the part in question.
  • Write down exactly what bothers you. “The grout is cracking along the tub” gets a better answer than “does this look okay?”

Ready for a read on your project? Start a Review.

A Review is a visual observation of workmanship. It does not replace a municipal inspection, a home inspection, or an engineer's assessment.

Let Me Take A Look

Proactive construction QA. Written reviews from vetted pros.

Keep reading.

A vetted pro. On your build.

Upload your photos. Get a written Review back. $49.